Speculators are back.
Oil prices have surged more than 50 percent since the beginning of this year, jumping from 30 U.S. dollars a barrel in the first quarter to currently above 70 dollars.
While the shift in the market sentiment and declining dollar have been much discussed, many believe that it is the reallocation of funds flowing into the commodities that has driven the price to rise far off fundamentals.
“The fundamentals do not support the recent rally in the oil market,” Raymond Carbone, president of Paramount Options, told Xinhua.
“We are at 18-year inventory highs, and there is no empirical data showing demand is being strong. In fact, demand is lower this year than this time last year,” said Carbone.
On Thursday, the International Energy Agency (IEA) decided to increase its forecast for this year’s global daily oil demand to 8.33 million barrels, 120,000 barrels more than its May prediction.
That was its first upward readjustment in 10 months, and the market reacted with a year-high record price of above 73 dollars a barrel.
However, the IEA still predicted that the total demand this year will drop by 2.9 percent from last year; and in the United States, the world’s top oil consumer, the demand will see a decrease of 4.8 percent.
The supply side does not look bullish either, at least in the short term. OPEC has decided to cut oil production by a total of 4.2 million barrels since last September, suggesting sufficient room in the spare capacity.
Meanwhile, despite a larger-than-expected drop in the crude inventory as shown in the latest U.S. Energy Department weekly report, the crude stockpiles are still standing at the highest level in 18 years.
“We are certainly well-supplied with oil. But the market is focusing on the resurgence of demand in the future (once the economy recovers) and that has really overwhelmed the fundamental picture,” Carbone said.
“I think there is a reentry into the market of the speculative funds. I think we are seeing speculation in commodities in general, and oil is included in that,” Carbone said.
According to a report by Merrill Lynch and Bank of America, commodity prices rallied in May as central banks continued to pump liquidity into the global economy, with most sectors showing strong performance.
Shanquan Li, vice president of the Global Equity Group in Oppenheimer Funds, said he had suggested that investors buy oil futures when the price was still around 40 dollars.
He told Xinhua that 40-dollar-per-barrel oil is the result of market overreaction just as the price topped 120 dollars, noting that in the long term, as the oil price rises with the economic recovery, and the gap between a rising demand and a limited supply will persist.
“For oil investors, 40 or 50 dollars a barrel is relatively cheap in the long term,” he said.
“There will be volatility in the prices given the unclear prospect of the U.S. economic turnaround, but the trend of oil prices is going upward,” he said.
Inflation fear is another force that has driven funds into the commodities.
Investors are worried that the trillions of dollars Washington is spending on bailouts and other initiatives will weaken the dollar and boost inflation over the next few years, while such dollar-denominated commodities as oil have historically been good hedges against inflation since their prices usually go up when the dollar weakens.
“Oil may be overbought right now, but there is the potential to see heavy inflation,” said Steven Stahler, president of financial advisory firm Stahler Group in Baton Rouge, Louisiana.
Analysts believe that the speculative funds coming into the oil market this year are probably the same players as last year.
“These are the long term massive players. They want to hedge against inflation and declining dollar. And they see commodities as an asset class that they must involve in to hedge against risk,” Carbone said.
Oil market has been following the boom-bust-boom cycles, and last year oil’s free-fall plunge following a rally into 147 dollars was a perfect example.
Now, with the weak dollar, market sentiment that is far off fundamentals and speculative funds–all were the factors that triggered last year’s dramatic move–in place, it is wise to be alert to a repeat of the “roller coaster.”